Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

Collapse

Ad Widget

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • [Question] Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

    I know people love to criticize Hollywood Studios, but when I used to go there in my youth I really enjoyed that place and especially the recreation of a romanticized old Hollywood/L.A. in the "Hollywood Boulevard" and Sunset Boulevard" parts of the park. I still really dig those areas. I love the building facades and the aesthetic of the architecture and just the overall feel of those streets.

    Since Buena Vista Street has opened at California Adventure, many Disney related sites have stated that it has been very well received and people were generally impressed. When I saw it for myself I was a little disappointed. I felt like the facades weren't particularly impressive and the interiors of the stores were pretty dull. I know Buena Vista Street is meant to represent 1920's Los Angeles, while Hollywood and Sunset at DHS are themed on 1940s L.A., so perhaps differing eras account for something. But overall I didn't feel that Buena Vista Street really "takes you to another place" as well as it's DHS counterparts, and isn't as charming.

    I was just curious to see what others thought. For those of you who've seen both, which do you prefer?
    What are your general thoughts?

  • #2
    Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

    There's not a giant hat in front of Carthay Circle Theater. Do I need to say any more?

    In fairness, the Hollywood Blvd/Sunset Blvd section of DHS is the part of the park that works best, but I think overall Buna Vista Street feels more complete thematically. You have the Red Cars, you have Carthay Circle Theater, you have (or had) the wonderfully designed window displays, etc. DHS needs the kind of attention that DCA just got.
    sigpic@Illusion0fLife

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

      Since this is a Disneyland site, I'm pretty sure I can guess what the overall pick will be.
      Princess of Agrabah and Queen of Never Land

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

        Believe me Illusion, I think it's ridiculous that they put the giant sorcerer's hat right there. But as far as the look of the streets and the storefronts, not to mention the layouts and design within the stores, I really feel DHS is superior in this regard. A lot of the stores on Buena Vista Street feel so dull and boring inside.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

          Wouldn't it be more "correct" to compare Sunset Boulevard not to Buena Vista Street, but Hollywood Land?

          Although I don't think the design is necessarily "superior"--it just sounds like you prefer the aesthetic?

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

            It has been so long since I have been to DHS that I automatically think of Buena Vista Street first. However I have to mention a lot of BVS was lifted directly out of DHS, such as the park entrance, even DHS has a (small) Carthay Circle Theater near the entrance. Yet BVS has details such as the Red Car, and the massive Carthay Circle...

            As such I call the debate a draw, both parks have their unique benefits.

            Yet, DHS has better details than Hollywoodland...
            sigpic

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

              Originally posted by jasmineray View Post
              Since this is a Disneyland site, I'm pretty sure I can guess what the overall pick will be.
              The results will surprise you.

              Especially if its Hollywood Land + Buena Vista Street vs. Hollywood Blvd & Sunset Blvd in Orlando.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                I prefer Sunset Boulevard, actually, for the 'big picture' with their far-superior Tower of Terror at the end of the street, and small details around the place.

                Don't get me wrong, Buena Vista Street is nice, and some good detailing also, but not a place I find myself wanting to just hang out in (unlike Sunset).
                when the spooks have a midnight jamboree....

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                  In that regard, DCA's Hollywood Blvd and ToT's placement are awkward.

                  The Red Cars help you find ToT, follow the red brick road - along the disaster that is a fake bldg and a fake skyline on a box.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                    Originally posted by RegionsBeyond View Post
                    I prefer Sunset Boulevard, actually, for the 'big picture' with their far-superior Tower of Terror at the end of the street, and small details around the place.
                    I've only been to DHS, but I think Sunset Blvd. beats out the other three because of the menacing appearance of the old Hollywood Tower Hotel, with it's broken down sign and it's flickering lights. If they were to add Red Trolley Cars to the street, I would not be able to handle it.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                      Originally posted by Design View Post
                      If they were to add Red Trolley Cars to the street, I would not be able to handle it.
                      Would you spontaneously combust?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                        I've never been to 'Disney's Hollywood Studios' but 'Hollywood Land' in 'California Adventure' just makes me feel depressed. Everything just feels lifeless, abandoned and foreclosed.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                          I'd say BVS because of the detail
                          if they do the same level of detail at DHS, it be close
                          Take a look at some of my models I make at kolbykonnection.com

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                            Originally posted by Mondo Mouse View Post
                            I know Buena Vista Street is meant to represent 1920's Los Angeles, while Hollywood and Sunset at DHS are themed on 1940s L.A., so perhaps differing eras account for something. But overall I didn't feel that Buena Vista Street really "takes you to another place" as well as it's DHS counterparts, and isn't as charming.
                            I would agree that it didn't take you to another place. We're in California park in California. If I was at DHS, I would feel less homesick.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Buena Vista Street (DCA) vs. Hollywood Blvd. and/or Sunset Blvd. (DHS)

                              Originally posted by StevenW View Post
                              I would agree that it didn't take you to another place. We're in California park in California. If I was at DHS, I would feel less homesick.
                              Don't know if you were trying to be a smart a$$ or not, maybe I should've said "take you to another time period" to convey what I meant.


                              As for Hollywood Land, yeah I feel that whole are is really weak too, even more so. It would be so much better if it wasn't just facades but actual storefronts and recreations of all the things they're meant to represent.

                              Comment

                              Ad Widget

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X