Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Napa Rose Opinions

Collapse

Ad Widget

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Napa Rose Opinions

    This is not meant to be a flame thread... but...

    Does anyone else think that Napa Rose is really overrated? I went there for the first time and while the food was good, I felt like it was a typical "hotel" fine dining establishment (yes, I realize it is indeed IN A HOTEL).

    The ambiance left A LOT to be desired for me. Maybe I got seated at a bad table, but with the high ceilings and somewhat sterile decor, I couldn't help but feel like I was in a Las Vegas buffet dining room. For fine dining, I am used to a more dimly lit, intimate environment.

    The service was fine, but not great. And the food was the same. Good but not great. I dunno, maybe I was expecting too much based on some things I've read. I would love to hear some other opinions.
    *A Republic... If you can keep it*

  • #2
    Re: Napa Rose Opinions

    Is it upper-class for Disneyland? Yes.
    Is it upper-class for the real world? Not so much.

    I do enjoy it for what it is though.

    Desires should not be hindered, no matter how difficult life might appear to be.
    If you fail, don't cease; keep going, keep trying.
    Giving up is never an option.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Napa Rose Opinions

      It didn't thrill me too much. I agree with WarningSLO. It was alright, but I actually prefer StoryTeller's much more. To me, it captures that "Disney quality" that I can't put my finger on, much better.
      Perhaps if I was a wine drinker it might mean more to me, but I'm not.
      http://micechat.com/forums/disneylan...oto-heavy.html
      http://micechat.com/forums/disneylan...ip-report.html
      http://micechat.com/forums/disneylan...oto-heavy.html
      http://micechat.com/forums/disneylan...oto-heavy.html
      http://micechat.com/forums/disneylan...something.html

      No matter where you go, there you are.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Napa Rose Opinions

        For a Disneyland Resort restaurant, it's top notch, easily the best you'll find.

        I find Napa Rose to be an excellent value for whats offered.
        Just countin' the days til the next visit!

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Napa Rose Opinions

          The Napa Rose gets very high marks from me consistently. The service is the best in the resort. The staff are well seasoned in fine dining and know the restaurant hands down. And if there is ever anything wrong, it will be made right. You'd be hard pressed to find better wine (or better bartenders) anywhere. I've dined there regularly since it openend and always recommend it....even if only for drinks in their lovely lounge.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Napa Rose Opinions

            The food was excellent and so was the service, however, I thought the atmosphere resembled an expensive bar. I have seen more people who imbibed too many libations (I'm being polite with my word usage) at my one time at Napa Rose than I have ever seen in all my times at Steakhouse 55. It felt like I was dining with drunks with money instead of a nice restaurant.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Napa Rose Opinions

              The Napa Rose is a great experience in food and service, but it's gonna cost you. If one just goes there just orders a main course and a drink, then you've wasted your money and time, its no different than going to any eatery. the experience lies in going all out and spending the time (and money) by doing it right which means cocktails, appetizers, wines, starters, main course, desserts, cognac, brandy or ports followed by a really good cup of coffee.
              sigpicI reject your reality and substitute my own

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                We were there last Wednesday, at 7. I guess it has a lot to do with what you are used to, to me NR is fairly upscale, very upscale for DL.



                We had perfect service. The waiter was prompt, gave us time to ponder the menu, checked on us when we needed something, but otherwise left us alone, no hovering. Perfect.

                Extensive wine list for sure. As with all restaurants, booze is where they really gouge you pretty heavily. A 200-300% mark up is fairly common. We settled on a nice Pinot from New Zealand. It was a great bottle of wine, $50 at NR, probably $13 at BevMo. Was it worth $50 to me at dinner, absolutely.

                We ordered the seven deadly sins appetizer. Essentially seven bites for $45. However, each of those bites was pretty darn good. Would I order that again, probably not, but glad to experience it nonetheless.



                So I would say it was well worth the money, but at the OP stated, take in the full experience, not just a cocktail and some calamari.
                They who dream by day are cognizant of many things which escape those who dream only by night. ~Edgar Allan Poe

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                  Originally posted by JB1 View Post
                  The food was excellent and so was the service, however, I thought the atmosphere resembled an expensive bar. I have seen more people who imbibed too many libations (I'm being polite with my word usage) at my one time at Napa Rose than I have ever seen in all my times at Steakhouse 55. It felt like I was dining with drunks with money instead of a nice restaurant.
                  That's actually an enticing review! lol ;-)
                  Yes, it's true....people do like to cocktail at the Napa Rose. But I've practically never seen anyone get out of hand or unruly. As for the atmosphere, I've heard it described as like being on a cruise ship. Which if you're sitting in the lounge, it kind of does resemble that.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                    I live within an hour of some of the finest restaurants in the world, I'd rate the Napa Rose in that class.

                    I've always experienced very good food and great service there, and yes, you are going to pay for that experience. For anyone who has done any wine tours in the Napa area, the decor at the Napa Rose is very reminiscent of a winery tasting room.

                    Having a drink out by the fire pit, enjoying a fine cigar, is a real treat, and I dare you to show up at any other fine eating establishment in jeans and a Hawiian shirt, and not feel completely out of place. Not the case at the Napa Rose.

                    Is the Napa Rose the end all and be all of the restaurant world (as I have heard claimed on other sites)? Not by a long shot, but, I think it holds it's own quite well.
                    My Disney blog: http://disneyhistory-myjourneyofdiscovery.blogspot.com/

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                      I give Napa rose two thumbs up



                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                        Originally posted by MagicKingdomBoy View Post
                        The Napa Rose gets very high marks from me consistently. The service is the best in the resort. The staff are well seasoned in fine dining and know the restaurant hands down. And if there is ever anything wrong, it will be made right. You'd be hard pressed to find better wine (or better bartenders) anywhere. I've dined there regularly since it openend and always recommend it....even if only for drinks in their lovely lounge.
                        I completely concur, and we are foodies. I would say the only restaurant in the area with a comparable wine list is Mr. Stox. The sommeliers at NR are very experienced. If you like really great wine, the Wine Exchange in Orange on Tustin off of the 55 is one of the best wine stores in Southern California, both in selection and price. NR corkage is very reasonable (I can't recall how much exactly).

                        The only time we had minutely less than stellar service was when we went when the park was very crowded over Thanksgiving.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                          Allears.net just updated the menu link for Napa Rose,I guess the menu changed.. but either way it all looks good!



                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                            Originally posted by WarningSLO View Post
                            This is not meant to be a flame thread... but...

                            Does anyone else think that Napa Rose is really overrated? I went there for the first time and while the food was good, I felt like it was a typical "hotel" fine dining establishment (yes, I realize it is indeed IN A HOTEL).

                            The ambiance left A LOT to be desired for me. Maybe I got seated at a bad table, but with the high ceilings and somewhat sterile decor, I couldn't help but feel like I was in a Las Vegas buffet dining room. For fine dining, I am used to a more dimly lit, intimate environment.

                            The service was fine, but not great. And the food was the same. Good but not great. I dunno, maybe I was expecting too much based on some things I've read. I would love to hear some other opinions.
                            Really? Are there other places in the OC you are getting Pheasant Bolognese with shaved Oregon Black Truffles and Pork "osso bucco"? I think Napa Rose is one of the better restaurants in Orange County and has a top five wine cellar, there are few equals in OC.

                            As to the high ceilings and decor, I guess it does depend on where you sit, I really like the big glass window and the open feel, but really love the Chef's Counter and the chance you have to talk with the chef. It is the greatest way to eat.

                            Bottom line, I don't find Napa Rose overpriced or overrated, I think it is deserving of the accolades it gets.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Napa Rose Opinions

                              I've only eaten there once. My wife and I went right after I took the Bar exam as kind of a way to unwind from all that studying. I remember, I walked out of the third and final day of the exam at around 5pm and had reservations for 6pm. We found the atmosphere pleasant and the wait staff very friendly and attentive. It was a great experience.

                              Now, as a fine dining establishment, we go every winter to Yosemite for a week and stay at the Ahwahnee. Their dining room is rated as one of the best in the world. I think Napa Rose is easily on par with that.
                              "Greetings, Starfighter! You have been recruited by the Star League to defend the Frontier against Xur and the Ko-Dan Armada."

                              Comment

                              Ad Widget

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X