Announcement

Collapse
See more
See less

Another NextGen disaster in the making.

Collapse

Get Away Today

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Krack
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by quizkid8279 View Post
    So, the adults who post in this forum mostly despise this idea. But what do your children think?
    They think Disney should install carts that sell boogers in Frontierland because the #1 favorite activity of their entire peer group is playing with boogers.

    Leave a comment:


  • lazyboy97O
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by quizkid8279 View Post
    So, the adults who post in this forum mostly despise this idea. But what do your children think?
    Who cares if kids alone like it? A lot of these interactive elements are very much things kids can get at home. Why bother spending all of the money to treck the family to Florida so the kids, and them alone, can have fun doing stuff they can pretty much do at home?

    Leave a comment:


  • Mr Wiggins
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.





    "You're dead if you aim just for kids. Adults are just grown-up kids anyway."
    - Walt Disney



    Leave a comment:


  • Virtual Toad
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by quizkid8279 View Post
    So, the adults who post in this forum mostly despise this idea. But what do your children think?
    That's an interesting and valid question. My kids don't seem to mind waiting in line, if the attraction is worth the wait. They aren't really interested in cheap queue games or "interactive" electronics at the parks. We visit WDW to get away from the Wii, Blackberry, TV and iPad. We visit to spend time with each other away from all that. In fact, my son and I played a great game of rock, paper, scissors waiting in line for Soarin' the other day and had a wonderful time.

    Leave a comment:


  • quizkid8279
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    So, the adults who post in this forum mostly despise this idea. But what do your children think?

    Leave a comment:


  • Dapper Dan
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    If these elements are being added to the queue, I don't care. Back in the old days there were random photos of kids in that same area anyway. If they want to bring a little of that back with some poorly designed vaguely Mary Blair style cartoon kid post cards made by guests, go ahead.

    However, according to the article, these poorly designed vaguely Mary Blair style cartoon kids are going to be projected during the actual ride. If that is the case, it's a really dumb idea.

    Leave a comment:


  • Erik Olson
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by ttintagel View Post
    I heard about this a while back and it disgusts me. It personally affects me even if I never ride iasw again. That ride is not only one of the most artistically pure creations in the parks, it's also one of the most thematically noble things the company ever built. I felt dirty just reading about what they did to the original California version, and reading about this turns my stomach. Money-grubbing vultures trying to squeeze another cheap, easy dollar out of one of the rare things in this world that's good, decent, and innocent.
    As much as I agree with what IASW represents to many who ride it, let's not forget that Walt rushed this attraction to market for Pepsi. I like the new elements in the HM queue and I like even better that I can bypass them if I choose to.

    Leave a comment:


  • Spongeocto4
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    I am sorry, but I think people are overreacting to this whole thing. I would prefer if Walt Disney World moved their attention on rides,parades, etc. It is an activity with electronics. What is the harm?
    Last edited by Spongeocto4; 02-19-2012, 01:44 PM. Reason: spacing

    Leave a comment:


  • Country Bear Fan
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by Bronco21 View Post
    I think the very first "Nextgen" type queue was Disneyland's Indiana jones and it was, is, and appears it will continue to be the best interactive queue ever created by WDI. I think a lot of it has to do with Disney/ TDO wanting to put it on rides not designed with it in place. It has been shoehorned into attractions that weren't designed for it and it shows. I'm not saying that it can't be added to attractions that weren't designed to have it, but it so far has not been done up to the quality it should be. I actually really liked the Space Mountain one but it still seemed kind of out of place. If WDI has the funding and isn't forced into doing projects that go against the companies original values, then it CAN be done tastefully. But if not then we get Haunted Mansion queue and TV's in its a small world.
    Did you read Flynnibus' post:

    "Yet it's funded by corporate and being developed by WDI. NextGen wasn't a WDW initiative, it is/was a TWDC initiative. Just because WDW is who is buying into the deployments doesn't make it a TDO project.

    The technology will find its way into most properties eventually."

    Leave a comment:


  • Grinning Ghost
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    I only get upset when these NextGen enhancements are not appropriate for the specific attraction. If they don't fit in, they don't belong.

    Leave a comment:


  • Country Bear Fan
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by Virtual Toad View Post
    We get angry because NutGen is being shoehorned where it doesn't belong. Why does Small World need the same techie gimmick that Test Track is getting? It further homogenizes an already increasingly bland experience.

    We get angry because, as they waste money whoring up attractions, those same attractions are physically falling apart. But hey, why worry about horrible paint jobs, exposed electrical conduit and broken animatronics when there's a shiny new TV screen to look at.

    We get angry because, in the midst of this obession with NutGen, park and especially queue operations are inexplicably less efficient than they used to be. Wait times for Small World are noticably longer since they reversed the queue. Plus you get to spend your time looking at the dirty backside of the queue clock. Or the dirty back hallway at Space Mountain. If it worked fine for 40 years, why mess with it now? It's either total incompetence-- or perhaps they want the queues to be miserable right now. Can't sell the public a solution if there's no crisis.

    We get angry because we know why NutGen is being introduced. And it's not about enhancing the guest experience.
    You're completely wrong!

    And it's not "NutGen". It's NEXTGen! People like you don't seem to understand. This is not something to get so bent out of shape over.

    Aladdin6592 is totally right!

    Leave a comment:


  • flynnibus
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by ttintagel View Post
    Yes, most trends do have exceptions. That doesn't mean they don't exist.
    Its just one example... the hyperboyle that only work happens when this stuff you are so against is happening (or unsafe) simply isn't true.

    Look at BTMRR right now, they are rebuilding static ride structures in addition to doing core work. All the lifecycle work WDW does simply goes ignored by those who want to jump and down over the company's other initiatives to add new initiatives.

    We can go back and look at the carosaul too just finished up.. no nextgen, no 'unsafe' crap. They do this type of structural overhaul constantly. EPCOT has had tons of this done lately including virtually complete ground up rebuilds in Japan, etc. But those kinds of things are completely ignored when we need to stomp our feet.

    Yes, they seem to have different operational standards in terms of what they will allow slide - but that doesn't mean they don't do anything.

    Leave a comment:


  • PSUMark
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by flynnibus View Post
    Originally posted by ttintagel View Post
    I haven't heard anything, but it wouldn't surprise me at all. The budget situation at WDW is so whack, the only reasons you're going to get the money for a major refurb is if the ride is unsafe or if they want to install something new.
    hyperboyle and shows people really don't follow all the activities happening at the property only jump in when high profile or controversial things come up.


    Look at the last Swiss Family Treehouse rehab for a counter example

    To a certain extent I think you're both right. The problem isn't that rehabs, refurbs, and improvements aren't happening - there are tons of examples one could point to to show that they are. The problem is that there is no overarching vision, direction, rhyme, or reason to what gets spruced up and when, and available funds for said sprucing can vary widely among different operational departments. That's why you'll have an absolutely gorgeous rehab on the Swiss Family Treehouse, while Splash Mountain is quite literally falling apart.


    FoxxFur addressed this problem in-depth in her 2011 year-end report:

    Leave a comment:


  • ttintagel
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by disneyfann121 View Post
    I love the new HM queue, and the new Pooh one is charming. Sorry, but I don't feel an obligation to jump on the hysterical purist bandwagon.
    Well, then it's a good thing there isn't one here for you to jump on.

    I'll keep repeating it: nobody's arguing against change qua change. The people who don't like the current crop of NextGen additions seem to me to have done a pretty good job of articulating the reasons they fail to be impressed.

    I like the Pooh queue; I wouldn'thave counted it as NextGen because it doesn't use cutting-edge technology. However, it wasn't built to withstand the pressure it would take, and elements are often broken.

    ---------- Post added 02-14-2012 at 01:19 PM ----------

    Originally posted by flynnibus View Post
    hyperboyle and shows people really don't follow all the activities happening at the property only jump in when high profile or controversial things come up.

    Look at the last Swiss Family Treehouse rehab for a counter example
    Yes, most trends do have exceptions. That doesn't mean they don't exist.

    Leave a comment:


  • disneyfann121
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    I love the new HM queue, and the new Pooh one is charming. Sorry, but I don't feel an obligation to jump on the hysterical purist bandwagon.

    Look, it doesn't change the ride, and it makes long waits much more palatable. And, as others have pointed out, it's not like anyone is forced to participate. Bottom line: the new interactive queues are fun. And isn't fun what a theme park is all about?

    In many cases, I wish that the company today was more like Walt. But this isn't one of them. In Walt's day, a queue consisted of a bunch of chain link switchbacks. Now a queue gives you something to see and/or do. That's not an improvement?

    Leave a comment:


  • flynnibus
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by ttintagel View Post
    I haven't heard anything, but it wouldn't surprise me at all. The budget situation at WDW is so whack, the only reasons you're going to get the money for a major refurb is if the ride is unsafe or if they want to install something new.
    hyperboyle and shows people really don't follow all the activities happening at the property only jump in when high profile or controversial things come up.

    Look at the last Swiss Family Treehouse rehab for a counter example

    Leave a comment:


  • ttintagel
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Originally posted by disneyFREAK242 View Post
    Do we know if Big Thunder will receive the NextGen stamp in this current refurb? . . . I for one am 60/40 (pro/not) on the NextGen project. Space Mtn I thought was cool and fun, Pooh was good, Mansion seemed kind of haphazard (as was said before). . . . But I am iffy on IASW, with the tvs and such. . .
    I haven't heard anything, but it wouldn't surprise me at all. The budget situation at WDW is so whack, the only reasons you're going to get the money for a major refurb is if the ride is unsafe or if they want to install something new.

    Leave a comment:


  • JCSkipr79
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    WDW is being reinvented. Into a giant video game/interactive experience that datamines its guests information when they are busy playing life size video games in the parks.
    It's too late to turn back. It's like a runaway train that isn't stopping till it goes through the station full blast, derails and explodes. Kinda like the dream scene in Hugo

    Leave a comment:


  • disneyFREAK242
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    Do we know if Big Thunder will receive the NextGen stamp in this current refurb? . . . I for one am 60/40 (pro/not) on the NextGen project. Space Mtn I thought was cool and fun, Pooh was good, Mansion seemed kind of haphazard (as was said before). . . . But I am iffy on IASW, with the tvs and such. . .

    Leave a comment:


  • RoryLAronsky
    replied
    Re: Another NextGen disaster in the making.

    I give it a decade more until Cory Doctorow's "Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom" becomes a reality, sans the Whuffie.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X