Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

Collapse

Get Away Today

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #41
    Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

    Originally posted by TylerDurden View Post
    I'm not a troll, but I honestly find the computer theming somewhat repetitive and it lacks originality after the first few scenes. The test track theme with the different segments of tests made more coherent sense to me, which made it more exciting...all of course, in my opinion.
    I can sort of relate to this, the first section after the initial climb seems a bit odd without the suspension and brake tests, they obviously had to find some other element to put in it's place, makes the scene seem a bit rushed.

    Comment


    • #42
      Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

      My first impression is that it's better than the old test track (not very hard to accomplish) but still not as good as World of Motion.

      The outdoor section looks like they didn't know what to do with it, so they decided to do nothing. It doesn't fit the rest of the ride at all.
      It bothers me when people selectively edit quotes to support whatever point they are trying to prove.
      sigpic

      Comment


      • #43
        Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

        Originally posted by BandM View Post
        I can sort of relate to this, the first section after the initial climb seems a bit odd without the suspension and brake tests, they obviously had to find some other element to put in it's place, makes the scene seem a bit rushed.
        Yeah, I kinda felt that about all the areas. Like, the environmental test rooms served a purpose in the last incarnation--now they could be anything. In fact, this whole computer theme means that not a whole lot is going on. I dont know, I just felt like at least in the old ride you had a clear purpose, to test the car, and this is just a bunch of random movements within a computer (which is no more than projections on a wall)

        Comment


        • #44
          Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

          This feels like Future World should. Dare I say the kind of inspired forward thinking that embodies every aspect of the attraction reminds me of the original EPCOT.

          I could never get over that the old version felt like and old junky facility filled with cardboard shrubbery. Do I miss it? Yes. But I'll take this new version any day.

          My only two issues: I think the power section would be better if it were enclosed and (this is less an issue with the current attraction) I still miss the original car crash effect.

          Originally posted by TylerDurden View Post
          Yeah, I kinda felt that about all the areas. Like, the environmental test rooms served a purpose in the last incarnation--now they could be anything. In fact, this whole computer theme means that not a whole lot is going on. I dont know, I just felt like at least in the old ride you had a clear purpose, to test the car, and this is just a bunch of random movements within a computer (which is no more than projections on a wall)


          And I have to disagree with this. There is a clear purpose here to test 4 aspects of the cars performance, one at a time. Each big/circle/ring signifies entry into a new test, and there are very clear results at the end of each segments. I LOVE how clear this is.

          I think when people say it feels like things are "missing" from the initial climb etc. it is because they are comparing it to the old ride (i.e. a test used to be here, and now there is not one here). I don't think this is fair, you have to approach it as a new ride. Think of that initial climb as the opening to PotC... it is setting up the environment you are about to enter. That section of the track has a different purpose now, not a lack of purpose.
          Last edited by cruise; 12-04-2012, 11:24 AM.
          Disneyland Wooooh!

          "You see- Everybody's got a laughin' place, trouble is most folks won't take the time to go look for it."

          Comment


          • #45
            Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

            Originally posted by TylerDurden View Post
            Yeah, I kinda felt that about all the areas. Like, the environmental test rooms served a purpose in the last incarnation--now they could be anything. In fact, this whole computer theme means that not a whole lot is going on. I dont know, I just felt like at least in the old ride you had a clear purpose, to test the car, and this is just a bunch of random movements within a computer (which is no more than projections on a wall)
            Eh, I think it's more a problem with the layout more then the concept, the test are pretty clearly marked however they're not similar enough to the original batch of tests and the layout doesn't seem suited for them. Or maybe it's the angle they took for this refurb, it's more about designing then testing something that's already been created.

            Comment


            • #46
              Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

              This thread is such a stark contrast from the comments I've seen on YouTube and on the rest of the internet as a whole. ) We really are the 1% here.

              Honestly, I prefer the previous version of the ride. No, it didn't belong in Future World. But it was a solid attraction with immersive theming that allowed you to believe you were really in a GM testing facility. All of that is gone now. Yeah, I suppose the aesthetics are more pleasing to the eye, but the transition from the indoor tests to the speed test outside is so jarring, it feels like you're going from Test Track 2.0 right back into the original Test Track. And they're two completely different rides, so that doesn't work well at all imo. They should have enclosed that portion in keeping with the rest of the ride... which actually doesn't feel much like a Test Track at all anymore. Maybe if they changed the name I'd feel better about it.

              Comment


              • #47
                Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                Originally posted by Santana View Post
                This thread is such a stark contrast from the comments I've seen on YouTube and on the rest of the internet as a whole. ) We really are the 1% here.

                Honestly, I prefer the previous version of the ride. No, it didn't belong in Future World. But it was a solid attraction with immersive theming that allowed you to believe you were really in a GM testing facility. All of that is gone now. Yeah, I suppose the aesthetics are more pleasing to the eye, but the transition from the indoor tests to the speed test outside is so jarring, it feels like you're going from Test Track 2.0 right back into the original Test Track. And they're two completely different rides, so that doesn't work well at all imo. They should have enclosed that portion in keeping with the rest of the ride... which actually doesn't feel much like a Test Track at all anymore. Maybe if they changed the name I'd feel better about it.
                In what sense? Every forum seems to be split on the love/hate factor for this.

                Comment


                • #48
                  Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                  welcome to micechat BandM

                  just wondering,what other forums???
                  Take a look at some of my models I make at kolbykonnection.com

                  Comment


                  • #49
                    Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                    Originally posted by BandM View Post
                    Eh, I think it's more a problem with the layout more then the concept, the test are pretty clearly marked however they're not similar enough to the original batch of tests and the layout doesn't seem suited for them. Or maybe it's the angle they took for this refurb, it's more about designing then testing something that's already been created.
                    Yeah, actually that's kinda what I meant. It just feels like something is not right IMO. In the original ride, there were clear segments and tests with purposes and outcomes. This version seems to be Test 1-computer, Test 2-computer, Test 3-computer. If they had built the ride to originally be like this, they could've just made the track one loop around the building and on to the outdoor section and it would be the same effect. I dont know, something's missing I guess.

                    Comment


                    • #50
                      Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                      Originally posted by mratigan View Post
                      welcome to micechat BandM

                      just wondering,what other forums???
                      Firstly, thanks, been poking around here for a few years. Finally got around to making an account.
                      Secondly, I'm not sure I'm at liberty to say honestly, I've seen people get in trouble with moderators for linking forums on other forums before.

                      Comment


                      • #51
                        Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                        Like it, dont like it, it slays me how people can judge an attraction based on a video, and not a personal visit to Epcot, and ride the ride. Thats when im going to make my judgement. From what i see, its a whole differant ride. Im looking forward to checking it out in Feb.

                        Comment


                        • #52
                          Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                          Originally posted by redrhino54 View Post
                          Like it, dont like it, it slays me how people can judge an attraction based on a video, and not a personal visit to Epcot, and ride the ride. Thats when im going to make my judgement. From what i see, its a whole differant ride. Im looking forward to checking it out in Feb.
                          Don't think of it as "judgment" but rather as feedback on what could be a "previsualization" by the Imagineers. If a previz fails to impress, then the Imagineers will do more work on the attraction. In this case, I have seen videos of both the previous Test Track and the new Tron version. In my opinion, something is lacking in the new version...
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                          • #53
                            Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                            I think without the ability to completely rip out the entire thing and start over they've done an amazing job. I can't comment as to whether I love it or hate it until I see it in person as video only relates so much, but it looks great. My only real complaint is the transition from the indoor to outdoor portion. I love the visuals in the theming there but it kind of breaks the story. They could have simply done something along the lines of trying to convince us our car was now being generated from a computer file into a real car and being created or something to throw us out. However it doesn't destroy the ride and the cost to enclose that section would have been massive.

                            Considering that I rode the original Test Track twice, hated it both times due to its lack of creativity, I think I'll much prefer this version which at least feels like it belongs in Future World. Now if the video screens still stay broken all the time and effects keep breaking just like they did all the time before then its still a problematic ride, but if those have been corrected, then great.

                            Comment


                            • #54
                              Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                              I think it's amazing.. and the closest we will ever get to a TRON ride here at WDW.:yea:

                              Comment


                              • #55
                                Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                Originally posted by Eckert View Post
                                I think it's amazing.. and the closest we will ever get to a TRON ride here at WDW.:yea:
                                Agreed! No kidding, eh? I'm still waiting on one of those. ( BTW, great avatar Zuse )



                                I've never been on this ride so it's cool to see it. Thanks for posting the video. I like the Tron-ish elements of it. .....but.

                                Something's missing. It feels flat. I recall in all the Disney books I've read about the parks' creation and imagineering that they always stressed how important the story was on each ride. They wanted to work out the elements of the story before making the ride to make sure they had an immersive experience.

                                This ride's story is like.... I don't know, eating cold cereal. Something's very flat about this experience. If you guys who have been on it are saying it's better then I shudder to ask what it was like before.


                                I agree completely with mratigan, this ride would benefit by having something else done to the outside. A series of lights that blink TOWARDS you to give an increased illusion of speed. Might as well just put the whole ride indoors.

                                Comment


                                • #56
                                  Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                  Did anyone else notice that when you re-enter the show building after the speed portion, they didn't remove the plastic curtain above the track... They just cut it off with a pair of scissors? :blink:

                                  Comment


                                  • #57
                                    Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                    We are not the 1%. The ride is definitely better then a sterile warehouse enviroment pretending to test anti lock brakes, weather "extremes", and lateral forces. Old Test Track was a joke. It had a story, but the story, it was just one fake test experience after another.

                                    I have been on TT2.0 and while I was there the responses from the crowds coming off the attraction were overwhelmingly positive! You Tube is not a means to judge this attraction. While I respect you prefer the older version, I cannot wrap my mind around why. This is a far better uses of the ride system, and I have NO doubt having been on it that if both test 1.0 and test track 2.0 were built from scratch at a new park, 2.0 would definitely need a larger budget to be completed. It is not a budget cut or a watering down of any kind. 2.0 is also considerably less commercial with Chevy then 1.0 was with GM. Aside from the show room at the exit, the Chevy Sponsorship is subtle (parts of the que) to to almost non esistent during parts like the design your car rooms, and the ride itself. Thank you for not beating me over the head with GM/Chevy this and GM/Chevy that.

                                    Journey into your Imagination was a budget cut. Test Track 2.0 is not. Mark my words, it will not be a flash in the pan, it will reestablish Test Track as Epcot's premier attraction, and it will maintain that status for some time to come. Stop reading the you tube comments, and start watching the guests coming off the attraction, look at their faces, their body language, and listen in at their excitement and you'll know this to be true.

                                    Gone will be the days where the most commen comment heard about 1.0 was "The outside part was fun".
                                    Last edited by Kidgenie; 12-05-2012, 02:34 PM.

                                    Comment


                                    • #58
                                      Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                      Enjoyed it from beginning to end....three times in a row! Didn't hear one negative word from anyone after exiting the attraction. Actually heard the exact opposite. Nothing but smiling faces and adults acting just like the kids that were with them! A YouTube version of this ride does not compare to the real experience.....so save your hate til after you ride it. Then, if you can pout from beginning to end, you have the right to complain.
                                      WDW-'73,'76,'77,'78,'79,'80,'81,'82,'86,'91,'95,'96,'9 7,'99,'00,'01,'02,'03,'05,'06,'07,
                                      Jan'08,Feb'08,Sept'09,'10x3,'11x5,'12x4,'13x4,'14x 2
                                      DL-
                                      '79,'81,'84,'91,'05,'07,'10,'14

                                      Comment


                                      • #59
                                        Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                        Maybe I shouldn't talk since I have never been on this ride. It just seems like, besides the dark part, the ride is just an ugly version of RSR. Can't they at least clean grime of the side of the building?
                                        "Nice work, pal" :thumbup:

                                        Comment


                                        • #60
                                          Re: First Test Track 2.0 ride Video hits the web

                                          Originally posted by Kidgenie View Post
                                          We are not the 1%. The ride is definitely better then a sterile warehouse enviroment pretending to test anti lock brakes, weather "extremes", and lateral forces. Old Test Track was a joke. It had a story, but the story, it was just one fake test experience after another.

                                          I have been on TT2.0 and while I was there the responses from the crowds coming off the attraction were overwhelmingly positive! You Tube is not a means to judge this attraction. While I respect you prefer the older version, I cannot wrap my mind around why. This is a far better uses of the ride system, and I have NO doubt having been on it that if both test 1.0 and test track 2.0 were built from scratch at a new park, 2.0 would definitely need a larger budget to be completed. It is not a budget cut or a watering down of any kind. 2.0 is also considerably less commercial with Chevy then 1.0 was with GM. Aside from the show room at the exit, the Chevy Sponsorship is subtle (parts of the que) to to almost non esistent during parts like the design your car rooms, and the ride itself. Thank you for not beating me over the head with GM/Chevy this and GM/Chevy that.

                                          Journey into your Imagination was a budget cut. Test Track 2.0 is not. Mark my words, it will not be a flash in the pan, it will reestablish Test Track as Epcot's premier attraction, and it will maintain that status for some time to come. Stop reading the you tube comments, and start watching the guests coming off the attraction, look at their faces, their body language, and listen in at their excitement and you'll know this to be true.

                                          Gone will be the days where the most commen comment heard about 1.0 was "The outside part was fun".
                                          It's just your opinion vs. mine. As for the original Test Track just being "one fake test experience after another", doesn't that still stand for the new version as well? ) It's the same general concept, just presented in a different way. I simply prefer the older version for it's believability, as I already stated, and that's all there is to it. Not much to "wrap your head around". And I didn't even mention the ride's budget at all, so idk what you're on about with that...

                                          Comment

                                          Get Away Today Footer

                                          Collapse
                                          Working...
                                          X