POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

[sanguinepoppet]

Spoilers!!!!


Theories on POTC and the lost love that broke Davy's heart

So here's my thing... on Tia Dalma's necklace... same figure is on Davy's music box... notice and compiled my theory the first time I saw the film... is that Tia Dalma is Davy's lost love... the one that broke his heart and basically drove him mad... she's also gets around, if you know what I mean, and does as she pleases. This is evident in the fact that Barbosa was in her bed in Dead Man's Chest, and the obvious mentioning of her old relations with Jack. So my further thought on the theory is that Jack not only pissed Davy off with not keeping his end of the bargain with the Black Pearl, but what is Jack was the one Tia Dalma went for instead of Davy? Hmmm???

The world may never know...

or we may on May 25th... 2007...

I know it's a bit out there but I just have to pose my thoughts... what do you think?

[disneygirl]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

I had the same thoughts.

[sanguinepoppet]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

glad I'm not alone

you know what I would kill for though? That music box that plays Davy's melody... I know they sell the necklace, but I'm not really interested in that much.

[Kuzcochik]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

glad I'm not alone

you know what I would kill for though? That music box that plays Davy's melody... I know they sell the necklace, but I'm not really interested in that much.

Technically the music box is the neckalce. it's just inside the one in the film... I wish the Disneyland ones had that in them (I'd shell the 20 or so bucks out to get myself on)

I think the Tia Dalma/Davy Jones idea is a good one, but I think it's too easy (I did like the twist about her picking Jack, but i don't think Jack's old enough to have been fighting over a woman w/ Davy... Davy's been at the whole Dutchman thing for years)
From what i've seen and heard (they had the props for the movie at the EL Cap and in the chest that held the DMC there were love letters) Davy was in love w/ a woman named Calypso. This could still be Tia, but maybe it's a relative or something.
I hope they come up with something really complex but understandable that resolves all this

[sanguinepoppet]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

Technically the music box is the neckalce. it's just inside the one in the film... I wish the Disneyland ones had that in them (I'd shell the 20 or so bucks out to get myself on)

I think the Tia Dalma/Davy Jones idea is a good one, but I think it's too easy (I did like the twist about her picking Jack, but i don't think Jack's old enough to have been fighting over a woman w/ Davy... Davy's been at the whole Dutchman thing for years)
From what i've seen and heard (they had the props for the movie at the EL Cap and in the chest that held the DMC there were love letters) Davy was in love w/ a woman named Calypso. This could still be Tia, but maybe it's a relative or something.
I hope they come up with something really complex but understandable that resolves all this

whoa... wait... the music box was not the necklace... they are two separate pieces with the same design


Oh I never did read the love letters... do you know where I can find copies of them? I'd like to read....

[thrax]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

if you go on wikipedia they talk adout it, i'll find it

[Tui]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

whoa... wait... the music box was not the necklace... they are two separate pieces with the same design


Oh I never did read the love letters... do you know where I can find copies of them? I'd like to read....

Off Topic:

What is that in your avatar? Because....I have a dirty mind and I...well...I don't know what to say.

[sanguinepoppet]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

Off Topic:

What is that in your avatar? Because....I have a dirty mind and I...well...I don't know what to say.

LOL! it's the bronze of Goofy's arm... I'm peeking through it... he's like in the thinking pose... it's in the Hub at Disneyland...

You silly... no dirty thoughts... this is Disney! :-p Everything is almost nearly rated all G... :-p


psst... by the way Cursive rocks...

[thrax]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

http://http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...e_Caribbean%29

here you go this is davy's history

[thrax]

pirates, what are we gona see?

what are they gonna put in the movie? what do you wanna see?

i herd that all of the other pirates painted on the wall of the ride are gonna appear in the movie

as for what i want to see? jack meet two Asian women and get slapped across the face while the women curses at him in a foreign tongue, i think that would be hilarious

[Kuzcochik]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

whoa... wait... the music box was not the necklace... they are two separate pieces with the same design


Oh I never did read the love letters... do you know where I can find copies of them? I'd like to read....

Honestly I thought they were the same thing because they had the same design. i figured Tia's was just on a necklace and Davy's wasn't.

And I don'tknow about the letters, I just stared at them through a glass case at the El Capitan

The wiki about him doesn't say much that we don't already know about Davy.. I honestly think there isn't enough known at this point that isn't based on conjecture

[Mighty Mikerscope]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

If you didn't hear already the most recent Disneyland podcast shows the chest with Davey's heart in it will be in the new Pirate's Lair on TSI. When you touch it, it glows and you can hear his heart beating.

[figment1986]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers)

good theory, perhaps their past is interconnected...

personally, who knows..

i cannot wait till may 25

[sanguinepoppet]

Re: pirates, what are we gona see?

what are they gonna put in the movie? what do you wanna see?

i herd that all of the other pirates painted on the wall of the ride are gonna appear in the movie

as for what i want to see? jack meet two Asian women and get slapped across the face while the women curses at him in a foreign tongue, i think that would be hilarious

ahhahaha brilliant...

well I want to see more flirting between Jack and Elizabeth... and by the looks of the trailer... I shall see just that. :-D

[hollywood1939]

Re: pirates, what are we gona see?

It looks like the Wicked Wench (the ship) makes it's entrance! No wonder they didn't use that ship first.

[disneygirl]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

Maybe Tia Dalma is Calypso's daughter or sister. Just a thought.

[sanguinepoppet]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

Maybe Tia Dalma is Calypso's daughter or sister. Just a thought.

OOOO I like the way you think... :-p

[cellarhound]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

You know... this is what I had been thinking...

Spoiler

1. There needs to be the appearance of the Wicked Wench
2. Davy Jones and Tia MUST be connected.
3. The ring Jack steals from Tia needs to return.
4. Norrington needs to be a captain again. And he needs to let Jack go again... and he needs to turn against the East India Trading Company.(In other words he has to remain basically a good guy. Messed up but a good guy.)
5. Will and Liz need to get married by the end of film 3. Bootstrap has to be there somehow...
6. There needs to be a wench auction.
7. Jack needs to hide in a barrel.
8. Jack needs to be found sitting on a throne in a treasure room.

If these things do not happen look for more sequels.

Also please use spoiler boxes...

[sir clinksalot]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

I don't think we need to use Spoilers. Everyone proceed at your own risk. The title says Spoilers and it means it. Argggh!!!

[Neverlandtink]

Re: POTC3 - Theories (Spoilers) (Merged)

I thought I saw something in the trailer and I'd like to know what y'all think

- It looked like to me, that Jack actually lopped Davy's head off in that stormy sword fight. I slowed the trailer down frame by frame (yes, I'm that big of a geek!) and it looked as tho Jack takes a big swipe, but is holding the top of Davy's head and then has this big surprised look on his face. Did anyone else notice, or do you think I'm way off base?

Sometimes I really hate the new trailers because there's so much information crammed into such a small amount of time that it's almost too difficult to comprehend.